/pt/ – Petrarchan


R: 17 / I: 2

Pawpaw and Commercializtion : Anonymous : 135 days ago : № 10655

Pawpaw, or Asimina triloba, is the largest tree-borne fruit native to the North American continent. Its oblong jade exterior conceals a soft creamy yellow flesh that can be described as an amalgam of flavors similar to mango, cantaloupe, pineapple, banana, and pear, depending on the cultivar. This medley of tastes may be due, in part, to its ancestry. Pawpaw is in the primitive-flowering Annonaceae family, whose members are typically found in tropical regions. Despite this, pawpaw can be found as far north as New York and as far west as Nebraska, thanks in part to its cold hardiness, as well as a natural insecticide in its bark and leaves. Though this description of pawpaw may lead one to believe that pawpaw could be a viable product for commercial production, there are significant limitations resulting from the nature of this fruit. The one most often cited is the fruit's rather short shelf life. The fruit is rapidly climacteric, overripening in a couple of days at room temperature, and this can only be extended to a week when chilled. Additionally, the fruit is easily prone to bruising, which leads to unappealing discoloration. On the cultivation side, the tree's flowers cannot self-pollinate and are protogynous, requiring multiple genetically different trees and days to ensure fertilization. Along with this, they are not visited by bees; instead, they are visited by less efficient flies and beetles. This tends to lead cultivators to rely on hand pollination to ensure maximum yield. After pollination, all the fruit on a tree develops at different rates and does not change color during this time. Strangely, even when a single flower produces multiple fruits, the ripening times differ. The only indicator of readiness is feel, as the fruit softens when ripe, adding further complication to harvest. There have been and continue to be efforts to overcome these limitations. There was a contest held in 1916 by the American Genetics Association to find the largest and best fruit from the species for study. In 1990, a research program was established at Kentucky State University dedicated to studying the tree. In 2022, the USDA began to include pawpaw in the agricultural census. Research articles are frequently published in journals, with the fruit as the focus. Even in the year of our lord, 2026, an article detailing the sequence of its genome was published. The fruit provides many challenges along the road to commercialization that could lead to breakthroughs in the understanding of other fruits. Maybe understanding the mechanisms of pawpaw ripening will lead to a better understanding of how other fruits ripen. Now, while reading journal articles, listening to academic conferences, and perusing the forums of cultivators, I have come to the realization about the food I eat and the culture I live in. The reason I don’t eat pawpaw every year or even knew about pawpaw even a few months ago is due to the market, and thus it is sort of treated as if it doesn’t exist. Going further, I see the food I do at the grocer because it is commercially viable. Meaning, all along the supply chain, the individuals involved in putting that product before me, to pick up and put down and pick up again, gained something from doing so. This may be an elementary epiphany to have, but I find it funny that it only clicked for me recently. At the realization of the effect the market has on me and the choices presented to me, I don’t know how to feel about it. Part of me says, “Well, it works,” and another part of me looks at the pawpaw and says, “But it missed this.” Anyway, that's what I wanted to share, let me know what you think.

Anonymous : 105 days ago : № 10974
market-logic domesticates for predictability as an end to profitability, nature-logic merely lives in order to spread seed
Anonymous : 104 days ago : № 11026
Another thought provoking post.I hope to be able to try the fruit of one eventually. There is a pun to be made about wishing to try something and the monkeys paw-paw. Perhaps I will become obsessed with the saccharine nectar and be driven mad trying to find the ultimate cultivar.
Anonymous : 103 days ago : № 11037
> Custard Apple (Annonaceae), Breadfruit, (Moraceae) and Soursop (Annonaceae) Sculptures of fruit important to the West Indian immigrant communities of London installed in Hackney. I posted these before here once but I really like them and they're relevant to the post.
Anonymous : 103 days ago : № 11048
Good post!
Anonymous : 77 days ago : № 11621
Fascinating post, thank you for sharing. There is a lot of interesting work that goes into commercializing crops; when I was in college I saw a poster board that had been put together by a student talking about commercial applications for a berry common to our area. The berries are quite tough so damage during transport wasn’t a concern, but there apparently just hadn’t been much research done on e.g. predators and diseases that might have a negative impact on yield. Very interesting to think that all of this work has to be done to economically scale these sorts of crops, and that there are still so many that are constrained to local or regional markets due to challenged with cultivation, shipping, and consumer awareness.
Anonymous : 54 days ago : № 12217
Bump
Anonymous : 52 days ago : № 12296
Pawpaws are in season until October. If you live in the eastern half of North America you will likely have some form of pawpaw festival happening. There are also a growing number of orchards that sell them, and many even deliver (though keep expectations low if it isn't overnight shipping). If you're feeling adventurous you should be able to find them in nature. They are understory trees and often favor environments near flowing water.
Anonymous : 42 days ago : № 12821
Bump
Anonymous : 24 days ago : № 13283 >>13400
>>13283 Yes, sometimes a frost after buds form causes them to die off and the tree only buds once a year. It could also be that the trees you see are actually genetically clones of each other, as pawpaws tend to propagate by sprouting new trees from roots (called suckers), which means it can't fertilize the flowers (needs two genetically different trees). Or maybe the other critters got to it before you did. Hard to say.
I see paw paw trees everywhere on my running routes but they haven’t had any fruit on them. I heard a freeze in spring led to a bad year for the paw paw but was it really so bad that the trees bore no fruit at all? Or am I just bad at this?
Anonymous : 20 days ago : № 13344
My mom gave me some when I went to see her recently. Grew up around them my whole life but never ate them, not sure why. They're great but I see how they wouldn't be for everyone. They're misshapen, mushy, filled with seeds. Its similar to all those weird fruits they eat in the Caribbean. It just so happens they grow in a relatively poor part of the country, similar to American ginseng. I just hope they never become a commercialized crop honestly
Anonymous : 17 days ago : № 13400
>>13283
I see paw paw trees everywhere on my running routes but they haven’t had any fruit on them. I heard a freeze in spring led to a bad year for the paw paw but was it really so bad that the trees bore no fruit at all? Or am I just bad at this?
Yes, sometimes a frost after buds form causes them to die off and the tree only buds once a year. It could also be that the trees you see are actually genetically clones of each other, as pawpaws tend to propagate by sprouting new trees from roots (called suckers), which means it can't fertilize the flowers (needs two genetically different trees). Or maybe the other critters got to it before you did. Hard to say.
Anonymous : 16 days ago : № 13426 >>13431
>>13426 It isn't though?
>>13597
>>13426 >>13432 So, I looked into this and the evidence is inconclusive. The pawpaw is understudied from a food science and nutrition perspective, due to the reasons listed in the OP (tiny market, not enough people eat them). There are compounds found in the fruit that are also found in other members of Annonaceae that have been studied, some of which have been associated with atypical Parkinson. However these cases were of a small portion of individuals in a culture that had those fruits as a part of their regular diet. So I would say that there isn't enough evidence to raise concern if you only eating a few a year. If, somehow, you were able to eat them on a regular basis or at high volumes then moderation would be advised until there is a better research based understanding of the fruit.
Do you think another reason you don’t eat pawpaw regularly is because it is toxic?
Anonymous : 16 days ago : № 13431 >>13432
>>13431 nah they're right, it is a bit, you need to eat quite a lot though
>>13426
Do you think another reason you don’t eat pawpaw regularly is because it is toxic?
It isn't though?
Anonymous : 16 days ago : № 13432 >>13597
>>13426 >>13432 So, I looked into this and the evidence is inconclusive. The pawpaw is understudied from a food science and nutrition perspective, due to the reasons listed in the OP (tiny market, not enough people eat them). There are compounds found in the fruit that are also found in other members of Annonaceae that have been studied, some of which have been associated with atypical Parkinson. However these cases were of a small portion of individuals in a culture that had those fruits as a part of their regular diet. So I would say that there isn't enough evidence to raise concern if you only eating a few a year. If, somehow, you were able to eat them on a regular basis or at high volumes then moderation would be advised until there is a better research based understanding of the fruit.
>>13431
>>13426 It isn't though?
nah they're right, it is a bit, you need to eat quite a lot though
Anonymous : 16 days ago : № 13434
There is something special to me about encountering pawpaws at a farmer's market, or someone's property. It reminds me of being a kid and getting a rare item drop in a video game. I saw some at the market the other day and asked "Do you think you'll have these next week?" She told me "I'm surprised we have them this week."
Anonymous : 12 days ago : № 13597
>>13426
Do you think another reason you don’t eat pawpaw regularly is because it is toxic?
>>13432
>>13431 nah they're right, it is a bit, you need to eat quite a lot though
So, I looked into this and the evidence is inconclusive. The pawpaw is understudied from a food science and nutrition perspective, due to the reasons listed in the OP (tiny market, not enough people eat them). There are compounds found in the fruit that are also found in other members of Annonaceae that have been studied, some of which have been associated with atypical Parkinson. However these cases were of a small portion of individuals in a culture that had those fruits as a part of their regular diet. So I would say that there isn't enough evidence to raise concern if you only eating a few a year. If, somehow, you were able to eat them on a regular basis or at high volumes then moderation would be advised until there is a better research based understanding of the fruit.
Anonymous : 12 days ago : № 13609
Another fruit most will never see for sale is the Cashew Apple. It too has a shelf lifes of a day or two unrefrigerated, and is sour when raw. However, every single cashew nut grows by itself on the bottom of a cashew apple, along with a shell containing some resin that's industrially useful (working with certain chemical products can cause one to become allergic to cashews). Billions of cashew apples are grown every year, and they are largely consumed locally to where they are grown, and even then mostly preserved into jams.


Reply to this thread


Plainchant v0.7.5 (1793716144) contact admin at petrarchan.com